Note: Don't miss the cooking challenge issued at the end of this!
Recently when looking through a friend's recipe collection I was surprised to find that she had 10 recipe clippings that were all basically the same shrimp dish. One might use oil instead of butter, or teriyaki sauce instead of soy sauce, fresh chilis instead of chili sauce, etc. I thought to myself, why on earth did she feel the need to cut out and paste into a notebook the same recipe. Then it occurred to me--to her they are completely different recipes. Many cooks I know are so afraid to stray from a recipe, that if they want something slightly different, they look for a whole new recipe instead of making the variations themselves. I was poo-pooing people's fear to experiment, but then I realized I have the same problem, but in the car, not the kitchen.
My husband has been trying to teach me stick shift for like the last 7 years. I'd have a lesson or two, get overwhelmed, and refuse to try again. This spring because we knew we were going to have only manual cars in Australia, I begrudgingly agreed to make a better effort. I would shudder and die, and roll backwards and make horrible screeching sounds. I proclaimed, "I can't do it!" Daniel looked at me very puzzled and said, "But you are doing it." I demanded to know what he was talking about. "You're getting from point A to point B. The car is moving forward; you're not hitting anything. It's not going to be perfect right away, you just have to keep practicing, but you are doing it." My only response was, "Oh." By May I was able to do some of the interstate driving when we went to Indiana. We're doing lessons now on left handed shifting while driving on the left side. Am I perfect--Nooo way. Do I still die a lot? Yep. But I'm trying to remind myself that I AM actually doing it.
The same applies to recipes. I think I've mentioned before that my first attempts at cooking earned me the nickname Torch. Have all my experiments turned out great--Nope. Just a couple of months ago I tried to make up a pasta dish with what I had in the fridge and it was awful. I dumped the whole thing in the trash. When you first try to experiment with recipes there might be shuddering, screeching from you or your guinea pigs, and the whole thing might die on you. I would like to point out, though, that you are are doing it. Something was cooked, you tried something new, and you hopefully learned something to apply toward future experiments. This is why you keep frozen pizzas handy. If it doesn't work, you and your family aren't going to starve. If you don't persevere, you're not going to learn how to get good at it, though.
To help walk you through the process, we're going to use a simple recipe that has nearly infinite variations you can try: Chicken Salad. Below is my default chicken salad recipe, which is itself a variation on what my mom used to make.
1.5 lbs of cooked chicken, diced
1 cup mayo
2 stalks of celery, diced
1 cup roughly chopped walnuts
1 cup red seedless grapes, sliced in half
1 tablespoon tarragon
Directions: put all ingredients in a bowl and mix. Refrigerate for at least an hour for best flavor.
Now, this is a very tasty recipe that never fails to get compliments when I serve it at showers. I could be content with it as is, maybe just switching up the bread I serve it on--croissant to sourdough bread. Maybe I'll get really wild and serve it over salad greens as an actual salad instead of a sandwich. I'd be missing out on many other great chicken salads, though.
So, how are we going to mix it up? Let's go an ingredient at a time and brainstorm.
1. Chicken: In this picture, I used 3 large chicken breasts that I had grilled the night before with a sprinkling of salt, pepper, onion powder, and garlic powder. I was grilling pork chops the exact same way and knew I was going to make chicken salad the next day, so I thought as long as the grill was hot, I might as well cook the chicken, too. At home, where I can get a rotisserie chicken at Costco for $5, I just by one of those and remove all the meat and dice it up. When I'm really in a hurry or forgot to defrost chicken, I use premium canned white chicken. It's doesn't taste as good, but in a pinch it works. My mom always used to boil a whole chicken, take the meat off, and then she also had broth to make soup.
2. Mayo: Don't like mayo, or watching your calories? Trying using low fat mayo, or half mayo/half fat free sour cream. You can also use half mayo/half Greek Yogurt. Don't like it creamy at all--use Good Seasons Italian dressing or your favorite balsamic, just enough to moisten the mixture.
3. Celery: Hate the stuff? Just leave it out. Want to add a bit of licorice bite? Chop up a fennel bulb instead.
4. Walnuts: Like the celery, if you don't like nuts, you can always leave them out. Do you prefer pecans, almonds, or cashews? Just substitute the same amount of the nut you like.
6. Grapes: Again, you could leave them out, but try instead diced Granny Smiths for a sort of chicken/waldorf salad. Dried cranberries could be really good, too. If you went for a Moroccan or Indian Curry spiced chicken salad, raisins, currants, or dates might even work.
7. Tarragon: My mom always used dill instead of tarragon. You could use 2 teaspoons of curry powder for a curried chicken salad instead. Add a little onion powder or garlic powder.
I'm issuing a cooking challenge here. I want to see you experiment. Here is a link to my Potato Salad Plain and Simple recipe:
http://durhamfoodandart.blogspot.com/2011/04/potato-salad-plain-and-simple.html. I want to hear about how you changed it up. If it was a failure, I want to hear about it; if it was a smashing success I want to hear about it. No fair cheating and looking up other potato salad recipes, just think what you might to change, and go for it! Take a picture if you can, and email me your story at durhamfoodandart@gmail.com and I'll update how it's going on the blog.